Seattle’s Regulations a Taking? Appellate Court Says Maybe [10/29/26]
Seattle’s Roommate Ordinance Faces a Physical Takings Test
A Washington appeals court has revived a lawsuit claiming Seattle’s rental ordinances took an apartment building’s value without paying for it. The ruling does not award a dollar. What it does is rarer: it lets a takings claim built on the combined weight of landlord-tenant rules go to discovery and, if the facts hold up, to trial.
The case is GRE Downtowner LLC v. City of Seattle, filed Oct. 26 by Division One of the Washington Court of Appeals as a published opinion. Published means trial courts across the state must follow it unless the Washington Supreme Court steps in.
What happened to the building
GRE Downtowner bought the 254-unit Addison on Fourth, a low-income building between Pioneer Square and the Chinatown-International District, in 2012 for $12.5 million. It then put $26.5 million into renovations to qualify for the federal Low-Income Housing Tax Credit program, which locks the property into affordable rents for 30 years. Citigroup, Freddie Mac, East West Bank and the Washington State Housing Finance Commission all signed off on the projections.
From 2015 through 2018 the building collected 90% to 94% of its maximum allowable rent and ran a positive cash flow. Then Seattle passed six measures in four years: the Fair Chance Housing Ordinance (2018), the Roommate Ordinance (2019), the Winter Eviction Ban (2020), the COVID-19 eviction moratorium (March 2020 to February 2022), the 180-day rent increase notice rule (2021) and the Economic Displacement Relocation Assistance ordinance (2021).
Rent collections fell to 87% in 2019, 73% in 2020, 69% in 2021, 56% in 2022 and 44% in 2023. Vacancy peaked near 45%. Security, maintenance and insurance costs climbed. Losses went from $683,000 in 2020 to $2.7 million in 2023, about $5.8 million over five years. GRE says it is in default on its mortgage and the building is worth nothing on an income basis.
GRE sued in October 2024 under Article I, Section 16 of the Washington Constitution, which bars taking or damaging private property without compensation. A King County judge dismissed the case in February 2025 before any evidence was gathered.
Why the appeals court reversed
The court’s central point is that a regulatory takings claim turns on facts, and a motion to dismiss is the wrong place to weigh them. It reversed on every issue the city raised.
Economic impact. The city argued the losses come from LIHTC rent limits GRE accepted, not from city rules. The court said the building cannot leave the program for 23 more years, so the right comparison is the value of the property as it actually exists before and after the ordinances. That is a question for trial.
Investment-backed expectations. The city said anyone in the heavily regulated housing business cannot expect the rules to hold still. The court disagreed. Entering a regulated field does not forfeit takings rights, and owners are not required to anticipate every possible change. Whether GRE’s expectations were reasonable depends on the regulatory climate when it bought, which was stable at the time.
Character of the government action. The trial court relied on the ordinances as broad public-welfare measures. The appeals court said that is a due process argument, not a takings argument. The real question is how heavy the burden is and who carries it.
Statute of limitations. Washington case law has floated three-, six- and 10-year periods for regulatory takings over six decades without settling on one. The court chose six years under the statute covering use and occupation of real estate, which made GRE’s suit timely. A three-year tort period is inappropriate because takings are not torts.
Per se taking. This is the holding owners will cite. Under the U.S. Supreme Court’s 1992 Yee decision, a landlord who invites tenants in normally cannot claim a physical taking. But Seattle’s Roommate Ordinance grants occupancy rights to a tenant’s immediate family, an additional unrelated resident, and that person’s family, with immediate family defined to include former spouses, former domestic partners, and anyone the tenant has dated. Citing the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2021 Cedar Point Nursery decision, the court held the ordinance strips the landlord’s right to exclude people it never agreed to house. That is a physical appropriation, not ordinary landlord-tenant regulation.
What this does and does not mean for Washington owners
Nothing in the opinion decides whether GRE wins. The case returns to King County Superior Court, where the city of Seattle will get discovery and the chance to argue that LIHTC limits, downtown conditions, or management decisions explain the losses. The city can also ask the Washington Supreme Court, the state’s highest court, to review the decision, with a petition due 30 days after the Oct. 26 filing. We expect it will. Because the claim rests on the state constitution, the U.S. Supreme Court is not a likely stop.
The ruling changes the landscape in four ways.
First, the cumulative theory survived. GRE did not challenge one ordinance. It argued that the stack of them, applied to one building, crossed the line. Courts have been reluctant to entertain that framing. This one did.
Second, the six-year window matters. Owners who believe a 2020 or 2021 ordinance damaged a specific property now have a clearer clock, measured from the ordinance’s passage, not from when the losses showed up.
Third, the per se holding gives roommate and occupancy mandates a vulnerability that other rules do not have. A per se taking does not require proof of severe economic loss. Cities that have copied or are considering Seattle’s roommate language will be reading this opinion closely.
Fourth, the case rewards documentation. GRE won at this stage because its complaint laid out year-by-year collections, vacancy, bad debt, and expense data against pre-ordinance projections that lenders and investors had vetted. An owner with a story but no numbers would not have gotten this far.
The takings route remains slow, expensive, and uncertain. Washington courts have upheld Seattle’s first-in-time, Fair Chance and winter eviction rules against other constitutional challenges, and the Ninth Circuit rejected a Cedar Point argument against the city’s COVID eviction ban in 2023. GRE itself filed friend-of-the-court briefs in several of those losing cases. What is different now is that a Washington appellate court has said a well-documented, property-specific claim deserves a trial.
For owners with a building that went from stable to distressed after 2019, the practical step is the same one GRE took a decade ago: keep the pre- and post-ordinance operating record clean and complete. Whether that record ever supports a claim, it will support a better conversation with a lender, a buyer, or a city council.
Source: GRE Downtowner LLC v. City of Seattle, No. 87886-7-I (Wash. Ct. App. Div. I), free to read.
About HFO
HFO Investment Real Estate is the largest multifamily-only brokerage in the Pacific Northwest. The company has 12 brokers focused exclusively on apartment investment sales in Oregon and Washington. Call (503) 241-5541.
- Subscribe to HFO’s Oregon & SW Washington Weekly Newsletter for Multifamily Owners, Investors & Developers on LinkedIn.
- Subscribe to HFO’s Washington State Weekly Newsletter for Multifamily Owners, Investors & Developers on LinkedIn.
- Watch HFO’s latest YouTube interviews and subscribe.
- Click here to read more of our latest investor insights.
- Click here to see many of HFO’s current listings.